Energy Made Easy
Home heating

Boiler Cover: Is It Worth It, or Should You Pay As You Go?

What boiler cover is and what it leaves out, what it costs against a yearly service and the odd repair, and how to do the sum for your own boiler before you sign up or renew.

By Last Updated:
On this page· 7 sections
  1. 1What boiler cover is, and isn't
  2. 2What plans include and exclude
  3. 3Cover vs paying per repair
  4. 4Things to check before you buy
  5. 5What you may already have
  6. 6Annual servicing on its own
  7. 7If something goes wrong

The short answer

For most people, no. Which? surveyed 10,064 homeowners in June 2025 and found people paid an average of £183 a year for boiler cover, against an average of £79 for a one-off service and £156 for a repair when one was needed. Its view is that standalone boiler cover “isn't usually worth it”. Cover can still make sense if a sudden repair bill would be hard to find, or if your boiler is old enough to be breaking down regularly. The sum further down shows how to check for your own boiler.

What Boiler Cover Is, and What It Isn't

Boiler cover is a contract under which you pay a monthly or yearly fee and the provider sends an engineer if your boiler breaks down. Which? describes it this way: “Boiler cover is a boiler insurance policy. If your boiler breaks down the cover provider will send an engineer to assess the problem and try to fix it.” Some plans cover only the boiler and its controls; wider ones add the rest of the central heating.

It is not a maintenance fund or a new-boiler guarantee. It pays for repairs to faults that the policy covers, within the policy's limits. It generally does not pay to improve a system that is working badly, and it rarely pays for a replacement boiler in full.

Insurance or service plan? Most boiler cover is insurance. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) classes home emergency cover as insurance, including contracts that “include an element of service”, and the Financial Ombudsman Service handles complaints about it as home emergency insurance. Some plans, though, are sold as service or maintenance contracts and are not insurance. The difference matters to you for one practical reason: it decides whether the FCA's rules apply and whether you can take a complaint to the Financial Ombudsman. The documents you are given before you buy should say whether the product is an insurance policy and name the insurer. If they don't, ask.

What Plans Usually Include and Exclude

Usually included

  • An engineer's visit when the boiler breaks down
  • Parts and labour for a covered repair, up to the policy's limit
  • An annual boiler service (Which? says cover “usually also includes” one)
  • On wider plans: radiators, pipework and heating controls

Common limits and exclusions

  • Boilers over a certain age
  • A cap on how much you can claim
  • Sludge and the system flush that clears it
  • Parts of the system, such as cylinders or water tanks
  • Some types of heating system or property
  • A replacement boiler, or all but a contribution to one

The exclusions are where plans differ, so they are worth more of your attention than the list of what is covered. The Financial Ombudsman Service, which sees the complaints, lists the limits it comes across most: restrictions around the age of a boiler, limits on cover for replacement boilers, types of property and heating system that aren't covered, specific parts that aren't covered such as cylinders or water tanks, limits on how much you can claim, and exclusions on shared parts of a building.

Sludge is the typical example. Which? says that where sludge has built up, the fix is a full system flush, “which can cost more than £400”, and that not all of the providers it looked at cover the cost. A plan that will repair the pump but not flush the system that wrecked it leaves you paying for the expensive part.

Repairs may be temporary. The Ombudsman notes that most home emergency policies only stop the actual emergency, so a repair might be a temporary one, and that this kind of insurance doesn't usually cover damage the emergency caused, such as a ceiling brought down by a leak. That is what buildings and contents insurance is for.

Cover vs Paying Per Repair: How to Work It Out

The alternative to cover is to pay for a service once a year and for repairs when they happen. Which? has compared the two for years and says: “For most people, buying boiler cover doesn't work out cheaper than paying for services and repairs as they come.” These are the averages from its June 2025 survey of 10,064 homeowners.

Average yearly cost of boiler cover against paying for a service and repairs, using Which? survey averages
In a year where…With coverPaying as you go
Nothing goes wrong£183£79 (service only)
The boiler needs one repair£183 plus any excess£235 (£79 service + £156 repair)

Which? survey averages, June 2025: £183 a year for a boiler cover package, £79 for a one-off service, £156 for a one-off repair. Averages, not quotes: your prices will differ, and a major repair can cost much more than the average.

On those averages, cover costs £104 more in a year with no breakdown and saves £52 in a year with one repair, before any excess. So cover only comes out ahead if the boiler needs a repair in about two years out of every three: £104 lost in the quiet years has to be won back £52 at a time. A typical excess, which Which? puts at £60, more than wipes out that £52.

To do the sum for your own boiler:

  1. Find your cover price for a year. Use the renewal price, not the first-year offer. Add the excess if there is one.
  2. Get a local price for a one-off service from a Gas Safe registered engineer. Which? says it should be somewhere from £70 to £110 for a gas boiler.
  3. Look back over the last three to five years. How many times did the boiler need a repair, and what did each cost, or what would it have cost?
  4. Compare the totals over the same period: cover each year, against a service each year plus those repairs.

If the boiler has not broken down in years, the answer is usually clear. If you choose to pay as you go, the sensible habit is to put the money you would have spent on cover into savings, so that a repair bill is already paid for when it arrives.

When cover can still be the right choice. Insurance is for costs you couldn't absorb. If a sudden bill of a few hundred pounds would mean going without heating, a predictable monthly payment has a value that the averages don't capture. The same goes for an older boiler that is failing more often, as long as the plan still accepts it and covers the faults it is likely to have.

Things to Check Before You Buy or Renew

  • The excess. Which? describes it as “a one-off fee, usually £60, charged when a company has to send out an engineer”. A plan with an excess has lower premiums. Which? found 22% of people with boiler cover have a £0 excess and says that is rarely worth the higher payments.
  • Claim and call-out limits. Which? found some policies limit claims to £1,500 a year while others are unlimited. Check for a cap per claim and on the number of call-outs as well.
  • Price rises at renewal. Which? warns that people with boiler cover “are often hit with yearly premiums that increase every year”. Note the renewal date, compare the renewal price with what a new customer would pay, and ask for that price. Check whether the plan renews automatically, and how to stop it.
  • Boiler age limits. Which? says some policies set a maximum boiler age for new customers, usually 15 years, and that some providers won't renew once a boiler reaches a certain age. Cover that ends just as the boiler becomes unreliable is worth less than it looks.
  • What happens if it can't be repaired. The Ombudsman says most home emergency policies offer “a cash settlement of around £250 to £500 towards the cost of a new boiler” when a boiler is beyond economic repair. That is a small part of what a new boiler costs.
  • The service. Is an annual service included, and will it be done on time each year? If your boiler is under warranty, a late service can put the warranty at risk.
  • Whether it is insurance. As above: check the documents name an insurer, so that you know the Financial Ombudsman is available to you.

On renewal prices, there is a rule worth knowing about and a gap in it. Since 1 January 2022 the FCA has required insurers to offer renewing home and motor insurance customers a price no higher than a new customer would pay, and its rules list add-ons sold alongside home insurance as within scope. When it made the rules, the FCA said it did not propose to apply them to products sold on a standalone basis. Our reading is that home emergency cover bought as an add-on to your home insurance is protected by the renewal price rule, and a boiler policy bought on its own is not. That is our interpretation of the FCA's policy statement, not a statement the FCA has made about boiler cover specifically, so treat any renewal quote as something to check and haggle over.

What You May Already Have

Before paying for cover, check you are not already protected in one of three ways.

A manufacturer's warranty. If the boiler is still under warranty, faults in the boiler itself are the manufacturer's to fix. Which? says the brands it recommends offer warranties ranging from two to twelve years, and that a warranty often requires an annual service to remain valid. Find the paperwork, check the end date and keep the service record up to date. The warranty covers the boiler, not the radiators and pipework.

Home insurance. Which? says a standard home insurance policy “won't usually cover the cost of replacing or repairing a broken boiler”, but that many insurers will add it as an extra, often called home emergency cover. It adds that this is usually much cheaper than a separate breakdown contract, though you don't get the same benefits. Check your policy schedule: you may have it already, or be able to add it for less than a standalone plan. Check whether the add-on includes an annual service; if not, budget for one separately.

A landlord. If you rent, the boiler is not yours to insure. GOV.UK says a landlord is always responsible for repairs to heating and hot water and to gas appliances, pipes, flues and ventilation. In England that duty comes from section 11 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, which requires the landlord “to keep in repair and proper working order the installations in the dwelling-house for space heating and heating water”. Shelter notes that a landlord cannot avoid it by writing a term into the tenancy agreement that makes the tenant responsible for the boiler. Landlords must also have a gas safety check carried out every year by a Gas Safe registered engineer and give tenants a copy of the record within 28 days, the Health and Safety Executive says. The rules differ in Scotland and Northern Ireland.

If you already have British Gas HomeCare and are thinking of changing energy supplier, the two are separate: see keeping HomeCare when you switch energy. If your HomeCare renewal has come in higher than last year, the HomeCare renewal checker works out the rise, writes a script for the call and gives you the dates to switch without a gap in cover.

Annual Servicing on Its Own

Whatever you decide about cover, have the boiler serviced. The Health and Safety Executive “strongly advises that all gas appliances, flues and pipework should be installed, regularly maintained and serviced at least annually by a Gas Safe registered engineer”. It is a safety check as much as a maintenance one, and for a boiler under warranty it is usually a condition of the warranty.

Which? says a one-off service “should cost somewhere from £70 to £110 for a gas boiler”, with an average of around £79, and that a good service should last at least 30 minutes. It also found that around half of people don't have their boiler serviced every year.

Book it for late summer or early autumn, before engineers get busy and before you need the heating. Ask for a written record of what was checked, and keep it with the boiler's paperwork. A service is also a good moment to ask the engineer to set the flow temperature properly.

If Something Goes Wrong

Complain to the provider first, in writing, and say that it is a formal complaint. If the cover is insurance and the provider doesn't send a final response within eight weeks, or you are unhappy with the response, you can take the complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service, which is free to use. The complaints it sees most often include claims rejected because the fault “wasn't an emergency”, delays in carrying out repairs, insurers saying a repair isn't economical, and the way the policy was sold.

If your plan is a service contract and not insurance, the Ombudsman may not be able to help, which is the reason to check before you buy. Your rights then come from ordinary consumer law and the contract itself.

Sources: Which? — how to choose the best boiler cover · Which? — getting the best boiler service · Which? — common boiler problems and repair costs · Which? — mistakes that invalidate a boiler warranty · Financial Ombudsman Service — home emergency insurance · FCA — home emergency insurance category · FCA — home and motor insurance pricing rules (press release) · FCA — PS21/11, scope of the pricing rules · FCA — PS21/5, general insurance pricing practices · HSE — domestic gas FAQs · GOV.UK — private renting: repairs · Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, section 11 · Shelter — heating, hot water and power problems. Figures last checked 17 November 2026.

Got questions?

Boiler Cover FAQ

Usually not while the manufacturer's warranty is running. A new boiler's warranty already covers parts and labour for faults; Which? says the brands it recommends offer warranties of two to twelve years. What the warranty needs from you is an annual service, which Which? found costs £79 on average as a one-off (June 2025 survey). Paying for cover on top means paying twice for protection against the same breakdown. Check what your warranty excludes, such as the radiators and pipework, before deciding you need more.

More on boilers, heat pumps and grants

What a new boiler costs, the free setting that cuts a combi's gas use, the heat pump grant and a tool for comparing installers' quotes.

Free, runs in your browser, nothing you type is sent or stored. All heating guides