Have both quotes in front of you. Type in the total price from each, then as much of the rest as the quotes tell you. Leave a field blank if the quote doesn't say: a gap is useful information, and the tool turns it into a question for the installer. It runs entirely in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent to us or stored.
Enter the total price from both quotes to see the comparison.
Everything else is optional, but the more you fill in, the more the tool can check. Nothing you type leaves your browser.
How to read the result
Start with the price after the grant. Some installers quote the full price and show the grant as a deduction; others show only what you pay. The tool puts both quotes on the same footing using the Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant of £7,500, or £9,000 if you tick the box for an oil or LPG home with no mains gas connection. If you aren't sure whether a price includes the grant, the tool won't guess. It tells you to ask.
Then look at what the difference buys. The “in one quote but not the other” lists are the most useful part. A quote that is £1,500 cheaper but leaves out the cylinder and the electrical work may not be cheaper once those are added. Ask the cheaper installer to price the missing items, and you have a real comparison.
Price per kW is a rough check, not a verdict. It divides the before-grant price by the heat pump's output. It helps you see whether a higher price simply reflects a bigger unit. It says nothing about whether that size is right for the house.
Red flags are prompts. Each one is a fixed rule that looks for something missing or for a large gap between the two quotes. A flag means “ask about this”, not “avoid this installer”. The tool has no view on what a heat pump should cost and no list of preferred companies.
What a complete quote contains
A quote you can rely on should let you answer all of these without phoning anyone:
- The price before the grant, the grant, and the price you pay.
- The heat pump's make, model and output in kW.
- The heat loss of the house in kW, and the outdoor temperature it was calculated for.
- The design flow temperature, and the efficiency (SCOP) expected at that temperature.
- Hot water: whether a cylinder is included, its size and where it goes.
- Radiators and pipework: which radiators are being replaced, and any pipework changes.
- Other work: a buffer tank or volumiser if the design needs one, controls, electrical work, removing the old boiler or fuel tank, and making good.
- Warranties on the heat pump and on the workmanship, with their conditions.
- The installer's MCS certification number.
- The payment schedule: the deposit, when the balance is due, and how the deposit is protected.
MCS's customer commitment requires installers to provide “clear, fair and transparent pricing and contracts, with no hidden costs or penalties”, and to explain how a grant is applied to the cost. If a quote is missing several of these items, ask for a fuller one before comparing it with anything.
The red flags explained
These are all the checks the tool runs, and the reason for each.
No MCS certification number
Ofgem says a system is only eligible for the grant if it is “installed and commissioned by an installer certified by the Microgeneration Certification Scheme (MCS)”. MCS suggests checking an installer's status when you get a quote, before you sign and before work starts, using its Find an Installer tool.
Grant deduction unclear
A quote of one figure with no mention of the grant could be £7,500 higher or lower than it looks. Ofgem's guidance says the discount must appear at the quote stage and on the invoice, so it is reasonable to ask for both prices.
No heat loss figure
MCS's heat pump design standard (MIS 3005-D) requires a heat load calculation for the building. A quote given before a survey may not have one yet, which is fine as long as you know it is an estimate. The heat pump's size and the price can both change once the calculation is done.
Sizes that don't agree
The tool flags three things: two quotes whose heat pumps differ in output by more than a quarter, a heat pump smaller than the stated heat loss, and one more than half as big again as the heat loss. These thresholds are ours, chosen to prompt a question, not an industry standard. A bigger unit is not automatically wrong, but each installer should be able to explain the size from their heat loss figure.
Quoted SCOP below 2.8
Ofgem says air-to-water and ground source heat pumps must have a minimum seasonal coefficient of performance (SCOP) rating of 2.8 to qualify. A figure on a quote may be the installer's estimate for your house instead of the product's rating, so ask which it is. For context, the government-funded Electrification of Heat project measured a median of 2.78 across 428 air source systems in real homes.
No cylinder mentioned
If the quote says nothing about hot water, find out whether your existing cylinder is being reused, a new one is included, or it has been left out of the price.
No radiators changed and no flow temperature
Either on its own is fine: some houses need no new radiators, and some quotes list them without stating the temperature. Both missing together means the quote doesn't show how the rooms were checked.
One warranty much shorter than the other
Flagged when one quote's warranty, on the heat pump or on the workmanship, is half the other's or less. Ask what conditions each carries, such as annual servicing.
A deposit above 25%
The Renewable Energy Consumer Code says a deposit “should not exceed 25 per cent under any circumstances”, and that a deposit and any further advance payment together must not exceed 60 per cent. That binds RECC members. HIES, another consumer code, insures deposits up to 25% of the contract value or £5,000, whichever is lower. Since June 2026 installers on MCS's redeveloped scheme no longer have to belong to either code, and MCS's own commitment sets no percentage: it says a deposit must be “reasonable, justified and part of an agreed payment schedule” and that the installer must tell you how it is protected. The tool measures the deposit against the price before the grant.
Questions to ask before you sign
The tool writes a list for each quote from the gaps it finds. These are worth asking of any installer:
- What is the heat loss of my house, and can I see the calculation?
- What flow temperature is the system designed for, and what efficiency do you expect at that temperature?
- Which radiators are you changing, and why those?
- Is everything needed to finish the job in this price? What could add to it?
- Is the grant already deducted, and what happens to the price if the application is refused?
- When will the work be done, and is that inside the time the grant voucher allows?
- What are the warranties on the heat pump and on your work, and what do I have to do to keep them valid?
- How is my deposit protected if you stop trading before the job is finished?
- Who do I call if something goes wrong in the first winter?
Ofgem recommends getting quotes from more than one installer. Ask for answers in writing; an installer who has done the design work will have them to hand.
What the grant does and does not cover
The Boiler Upgrade Scheme pays £7,500 towards an air source or ground source heat pump in England and Wales. Until 31 March 2027, homes heated by oil or LPG with no mains gas connection can get an additional £1,500; our oil and LPG grant page has the conditions. It is one grant per property, and the installer applies for it.
It is a fixed sum off the installation, not a percentage, so it doesn't grow if the job gets bigger. Anything above the grant is yours to pay, including extras that were left out of the quote. You cannot get it for a hybrid system that keeps a gas or oil boiler alongside the heat pump, or to replace an existing low carbon heating system.
Scotland has its own Home Energy Scotland Grant and Loan, and the scheme doesn't run in Northern Ireland, so the grant figure in the tool applies only to England and Wales. To borrow for what is left after the grant, see the Warm Homes Loan guide. For the basics of how heat pumps work and what they are like to live with, see the heat pumps guide.
Sources: GOV.UK: Boiler Upgrade Scheme, what you can get · GOV.UK: Boiler Upgrade Scheme, how to apply · Ofgem: Boiler Upgrade Scheme, property owners · Ofgem: Boiler Upgrade Scheme, installers · Ofgem: Boiler Upgrade Scheme guidance for installers, V5.2 (3 November 2026) · MCS: find an installer · MCS: air source heat pumps · MCS Customer Commitment · MCS: MIS 3005-D heat pump design standard · Renewable Energy Consumer Code, section 6.3 · HIES: deposit and stage payment protection · Energy Systems Catapult: Electrification of Heat project reports (December 2024). Figures last checked 17 November 2026.