We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes our verdict. How we make money
Have your renewal letter to hand. British Gas says it contacts you at least 25 days before your agreement renews, so you should have a few weeks. The checker runs in your browser and nothing you type is sent to us or stored.
Enter last year's price and the renewal price to see your result.
Add the renewal date for the switch timeline and calendar file.
Like-for-like alternatives to HomeCare Two
Prices checked 18 November 2026Plans covering boiler, controls and central heating, priced at a £60 excess or the nearest each provider publishes. All figures are from the providers' own pages.
- Same cover areas
Hometree
Your Heating
£16.72 a month
£200.64 a year, £60 excess
An offer price. Hometree's standard price is £19 a month (£228 a year).
- Excess options
- £0, £60, £95
- Wait before you can claim
- 14 days
- Annual boiler service
- Included
Black Friday price for new customers, on sale until 3 December 2026. Hometree says the discount ends at renewal.
Any age of mains gas boiler. If one over 7 years old can't be repaired, Hometree doesn't pay for a replacement but offers 15% off one.
See plan: Hometree Your Heating, opens Hometree's site in a new tabOpens Hometree's own site. Checked 18 November 2026.
- Same cover areas
Openfix
Heating
£17 a month
£204 a year, £60 excess
An offer price. Openfix's standard price is £28 a month (£336 a year).
- Excess options
- £0, £60, £99, £139
- Wait before you can claim
- 13 days
- Annual boiler service
- Included
Shown on Openfix's site as a discount from a 'was' price. It doesn't say how long the discount lasts. Monthly Direct Debit.
Any age of mains gas boiler in working order when you join. A service agreement, not an insurance policy.
See plan: Openfix Heating, opens Openfix's site in a new tabOpens Openfix's own site. Checked 18 November 2026.
- Same cover areas
HomeServe
Gas Boiler and Central Heating cover
£8.99 a month
£107.88 a year, £60 excess
HomeServe says to expect about £27.20 a month (£326.40 a year) in year two if you haven't claimed.
Not like for like: no annual service in this price.
- Excess options
- £60
- Wait before you can claim
- 28 days
- Annual boiler service
- Not included
Sale price, HomeServe says, until 10 February 2027.
A first-year introductory price. HomeServe says claims history is taken into account at renewal.
Mains gas boilers only, no age limit to join. If a boiler over 7 years old can't be repaired, you pay for installing the replacement.
See plan: HomeServe Gas Boiler and Central Heating cover, opens HomeServe's site in a new tabOpens HomeServe's own site. Checked 18 November 2026.
Hometree's no price hikes promise: Hometree says that if you buy a core plan direct from its site and don't claim in your first year, it will cap your renewal rise at inflation, currently 4%. It reviews that figure every three months, and the promise excludes plans bought at a discounted first-year price, so it does not appear to cover the offer prices shown here. Read Hometree's terms for it.
Why HomeCare renewals jump
You don't need to have claimed. British Gas's HomeCare terms say it reviews premiums every year “based on claims history and other factors, such as regulatory or commercial changes that prompt a change in rates”. Its pricing guide lists the other factors:
- The introductory price ending. New customers get a first-year discount. British Gas says renewals are “charged in accordance with our standard pricing”, so a second-year jump can be the discount falling away with nothing else changing.
- Your boiler getting older. The guide says an ageing boiler “can mean your price increases when you renew”.
- Inflation and tax. “Our prices may rise with inflationary costs and changes in taxation.”
- Changes to your cover. Adding a product, or changing the excess, changes the price.
The excess is the lever most people miss. It is what you pay towards each completed repair, and British Gas says the higher the excess you choose, the lower the price. Its options tend to be £0, £60 and £99. If you rarely call an engineer, a higher excess can undo much of a rise. If you had three repairs last year, a lower one may be worth paying for. Check the excess on the renewal against last year's before comparing the two prices.
How to haggle: what to say and when to call
When: after the renewal letter arrives and before the renewal date. You then have every option open: accept a better price, change the excess, or leave. British Gas's lines for HomeCare are open Monday to Friday 8am to 8pm, Saturday and Sunday 8am to 6pm, on 0333 202 9343.
What to say: the checker writes the script from your numbers. The shape is always the same.
- State the rise in pounds. “Last year I paid £X, the renewal is £Y.”
- Give a comparison. A like-for-like price from another provider, with the same excess and an annual service.
- Ask for a specific figure, then ask what the best price is if they can't meet it.
- Ask about the excess. A different excess may get you to the price you want.
- Say you will cancel the renewal if you can't agree, and confirm there is no charge for doing so.
The price the checker suggests is a starting point: last year's price, or the cheapest like-for-like alternative if that is higher. British Gas has not agreed to it and may say no. If it does, you have lost a phone call.
One thing not to plan on: cancelling and rejoining as a new customer. The terms say that if you cancel and buy a similar product “within three months”, or more than once in three years, you “may not be eligible for any promotional offers or new customer prices”.
Switching without a gap: the 14-day rule, both ways
Two waiting periods matter, and they point in opposite directions.
The new policy's wait. A new plan won't pay for a repair in its first days: on the plans we compare, Hometree 14 days, Openfix 13 days and HomeServe 28 days. So start the new policy that many days before HomeCare ends, and the wait is over by the time you depend on it. About two weeks is the common figure, but not the only one, so check the plan you pick.
British Gas's 14-day cooling-off period. If HomeCare renews and you cancel within 14 days, British Gas gives a full refund, provided it hasn't carried out any work. The 14 days begin on the renewal date, or the day you received the agreement documents if that was later.
Put together: start the new cover early, let its wait run out, then cancel British Gas before the renewal or inside the 14 days after it. If you are short of time, the 14 days after renewal are your safety net. HomeCare keeps you covered while the new policy's wait runs down.
What costs money is work done after the renewal date. Cancel within 14 days after a service and the charge is £65 per boiler or appliance; after a boiler or central heating repair it is £155, and £70 for other repairs. Cancel after 14 days and you pay for the days covered plus a possible £30 admin fee, with the £65 service charge on top if the boiler has been serviced since renewal. After a repair there is no refund at all. British Gas says you never pay more than the product's annual cost. The full table is in the HomeCare terms (PDF), under “Cancelling your agreement”.
When staying with British Gas makes sense
- You claimed recently. New providers exclude faults that existed before you joined. If this year's repair might not be the end of it, staying keeps that fault covered, and British Gas doesn't charge a second excess for a related fault within twelve months.
- Your boiler is old. Read what each plan does when a boiler can't be repaired. The terms differ a lot between providers and by boiler age, and an old boiler is the one most likely to test them.
- Your heating has a known weak spot. With a new provider, the first breakdown is where a dispute over whether the fault was already there can start. A system British Gas has covered for years is less exposed to that.
- The saving is small. A first-year price from a new provider is often introductory too. If the gap is a few pounds a month, you may be having the same conversation with someone else in twelve months.
Hometree has a promise aimed at that last point. Hometree says that if you buy a core plan direct from its site and don't claim in your first year, it will cap your renewal rise at inflation, currently 4%. It reviews that figure every three months, and the promise excludes plans bought at a discounted first-year price, so it does not appear to cover the offer prices shown here. Hometree's terms for it are here.
And there is a third option. If you have had cover for years and rarely used it, our guide to whether boiler cover is worth it shows how to compare any plan with paying for a service and repairs as they come. If you are also changing gas and electricity supplier, HomeCare carries on when you switch energy.
How the checker decides
The verdict is a fixed rule of thumb, and these thresholds are ours, not an industry standard:
- Haggle first if you had a repair this year, or if the rise is under 10% and under £25 a year.
- Switch if you haven't claimed and a like-for-like plan is at least 15% and £30 a year cheaper than the renewal. Where a provider publishes a standard price or a second-year price alongside an offer, the plan has to clear that bar at the higher figure, so a first-year discount alone doesn't produce a “switch”.
- Haggle first, switch if they won't move for everything in between.
“Like for like” means a plan that covers at least the same areas, includes an annual boiler service as HomeCare does, and is priced at an excess no higher than yours. A plan that fails one of those still appears, marked “not like for like”, but doesn't count towards the verdict or the price in your script.
Every plan figure comes from the provider's own website, checked on 18 November 2026. Where a provider doesn't publish something, the card says “Check on site” instead of guessing. Prices can depend on your postcode and boiler, so treat them as a guide and get a quote before you cancel anything.
Sources: British Gas: HomeCare range terms and conditions (PDF) · British Gas: HomeCare pricing guide · British Gas: boiler and heating cover · Hometree: Your Home · Openfix: Home · HomeServe: Gas Boiler cover · HomeServe: Gas Boiler and Central Heating cover · HomeServe: Heating, Plumbing and Electrics cover with service · Openfix: Service Agreement · Hometree: no price hikes. Figures last checked 18 November 2026.